Buffalo Exchange @ W Cary St

Buffalo Exchange in Carytown has a bit of a mixed bag situation going on. The space is cramped and can feel overwhelming, but the shoe selection surprisingly shines. While their prices run higher than typical thrift stores and their buying rates are pretty stingy, you might score some decent mid-range finds if you're patient. The staff is generally friendly, especially Caity and Simi, who make the shopping experience more enjoyable. It's an okay spot if you're already in the area, but I wouldn't make a special trip. Free parking is a plus, though!